Skip to main content

Orion Dental Care, GK 1

When a tooth is badly damaged or infected, you may be offered a root canal, an extraction or an implant. This guide explains how the decision is usually made.

Key points

  • If a tooth can be saved reliably and restored, keeping your own tooth is usually the first choice.
  • Root canal treatment suits a tooth with enough sound structure, healthy supporting bone and gum, and importance to your bite or smile.1
  • In a review of 14 studies, between 86 and 93 percent of treated teeth were still in place after 2 to 10 years.2
  • After extraction, the options are an implant, a bridge, a denture or leaving the gap.
  • The bone needs about three to six months to bond to an implant, so the implant path takes much longer.

A tooth that is very painful, badly decayed or infected raises a big question: should you try to save it, or take it out? The answer depends on how much of the tooth is left, how healthy the gum and bone around it are, and what you want. It is not always a choice between a root canal and an implant, because the options come in an order.

Step one: can the tooth be saved?

Root canal treatment is advised when the pulp of a tooth is infected or damaged, and the dentist decides after an examination and X-rays whether the tooth can be saved.1 It removes the infected pulp, cleans and shapes the inside of the tooth and fills and seals it so that it does not become infected again.1 If an infected tooth is not treated with root canal treatment, the NHS says it may need to be extracted.1

Root canal treatment suits a tooth that:

  • has enough sound structure left to be restored with a filling or crown;
  • has healthy supporting bone and gum;
  • is important to keep, such as a front tooth or a tooth that holds a bridge or denture.

It may not be possible when a tooth is too badly broken or too weakened to be restored, or the patient cannot return for the appointments needed to finish and restore the tooth.1

Our articles on root canal infections and our page on root canal treatment explain the process.

What the research says about root canal outcomes

In a review of 14 studies, between 86 and 93 percent of treated teeth were still in place after 2 to 10 years, and survival was higher for teeth with a crown, with contact on both sides, that were not bridge or denture supports and that were not molars.2 Pain was common before treatment, and in a systematic review the share of patients with pain fell from 81 percent before treatment to 40 percent after a day and 11 percent after a week, although extra anaesthetic was often needed.3

After root canal treatment the tooth is usually restored with a filling or a crown, and teeth with a crown afterwards survived longest.12 See dental crowns.

Step two: when to extract

Extraction is considered when a tooth cannot be saved or is not worth saving. The most frequent reasons are decay and gum infection, and teeth are also taken out when they are broken, when they have no room to come through, or when the mouth needs space for other treatment.5 Read more on our page about tooth extraction.

A tooth with severe decay that cannot be filled or crowned, or gum disease so advanced that the tooth is loose and cannot be saved, are typical reasons.5

Step three: what replaces it?

After extraction, the options are the same as for any missing tooth:

  • an implant, a titanium post in the bone that carries a crown, so the neighbouring teeth are not shaped;4
  • a bridge, which uses the teeth either side;
  • a denture, which is removable;
  • leaving the gap, which is sometimes reasonable.

Our guides to dental implants and what happens if you leave a gap help with the choice.

Comparing the paths

Root canal Extract and implant
What is kept Your own tooth A replacement for it
Visits Usually two or more, of one to two hours each Several, over many months
Time A few weeks, with a crown to follow Several months, as the bone needs three to six months to bond4
Surgery None beyond the treatment Extraction, then implant surgery
Key risk The tooth can still be lost, or reinfected The implant may not bond, and the gum can be inflamed

The NHS says root canal treatment usually takes two or more appointments of one to two hours each, with a temporary filling between visits.1

Questions that help you decide

  1. How much of my tooth is left above the gum?
  2. How healthy are the bone and gum around it?
  3. What is the chance of saving it, and what happens if it fails?
  4. What would the replacement involve?
  5. How important is this tooth to my bite or smile?
  6. What are the time and visits for each path?

The general principle

If a tooth can be saved reliably and restored, keeping your own tooth is usually the first choice. If it cannot, or the chance is poor, removal followed by a replacement is reasonable. Implants are an excellent option after an extraction but are not a reason to remove a tooth that could be kept. Always ask for a second opinion if you are unsure.

What a second opinion should add

If you have been advised to extract a tooth and you are unsure, a second opinion is reasonable. A second dentist can look at the same X-rays and examine the tooth, and tell you whether they agree. A helpful second opinion explains why the tooth can or cannot be saved, what would be involved and what the long-term plan is for each choice.

Bring your X-rays, notes and any treatment plan you have been given. Ask the first dentist for copies, and say plainly that you would like another view. Make sure you ask the same questions of each dentist, so you can compare answers fairly.

Protecting the socket after an extraction

If you decide on extraction, protect the healing socket. A blood clot forms in the space, and keeping it in place helps healing and prevents dry socket.

  • Do not rinse vigorously or spit hard for the first day.
  • Avoid smoking, which delays healing.
  • Eat soft, cool food, and avoid the extraction side.
  • Do not poke the area with a tongue or finger.
  • Follow your dentist's instructions on rinsing, medicines and cleaning.
  • Call the clinic if pain gets worse after the first couple of days, if there is a bad taste, or if bleeding continues.

Ask when the replacement can be planned. If an implant is likely, the dentist may suggest keeping the bone in good shape from the start.

Thinking about the long term

Each path has upkeep. A root-treated tooth needs a filling or crown, careful cleaning and check-ups, and it can still fracture or be reinfected. An implant needs daily cleaning around it, check-ups every three to six months and, over time, repair of the crown or screw.4 A bridge needs careful cleaning beneath it, and a denture needs daily cleaning and occasional relining.

Think about which kind of upkeep you can manage, and what you would do if the first choice did not work. Ask your dentist what the plan would be if a root canal failed or an implant did not bond, since each can be followed by another option.

Myths and facts

Myth: a root canal is always painful. A local anaesthetic is given, so you are awake but should not feel pain.1

Myth: it is better to remove a painful tooth than to treat it. If a tooth can be saved and restored, keeping it is usually a good aim, and removal is the alternative if it cannot be saved.1

Myth: an implant is better than a root-treated tooth. Neither is better in every case. The right choice depends on the tooth and on the mouth.

After each path

After a root canal: the tooth is usually restored with a filling or a crown, and teeth with a crown survived longest in a review.2 Avoid knocking or biting hard on the tooth, and keep your follow-up appointments.1

After an extraction: protect the socket while it heals, and discuss the replacement. Our page on tooth extraction explains the aftercare.

After an implant: the bone needs about three to six months to bond to the post, and check-ups follow.4

Frequently asked questions

Is root canal treatment painful?

A local anaesthetic is given, so you are awake but should not feel pain.1 Pain after treatment usually falls quickly.3

Can a root-treated tooth be lost later?

Yes. In 14 studies, 86 to 93 percent of treated teeth were still in place after 2 to 10 years.2

Can an implant be placed at the same time as the extraction?

Sometimes, if the bone and gum allow and there is no infection. Your dentist decides after an examination and imaging.4

Does it matter if I choose to leave the gap?

Gaps can cause problems over time, and it is worth discussing what is likely for your mouth.

Can a root-treated tooth be crowned later?

Yes, and a crown afterwards helped teeth survive longest in a review.2

Is an extraction always the end of the tooth?

Yes, but its replacement can be a bridge, an implant or a denture.

Which lasts longer, a root-treated tooth or an implant?

It depends on the tooth and how it is cared for. Reviews give group figures that cannot be compared directly, and each has its own risks. A dentist can tell you which is more suitable for your tooth.2

Can I keep a tooth that a dentist says is hopeless?

Sometimes a second opinion finds a way to save it, but sometimes the original advice is right. Ask each dentist why the tooth can or cannot be restored.

About the author

Portrait of Dr Anupam Sinha

Dr Anupam Sinha, BDS, MDS – Orthodontics. BDS (2002), KLE Vishwanath Katti Institute of Dental Sciences, Belgaum. MDS in Orthodontics (2006), SDM College of Dental Sciences, Dharwad. His thesis work won a national research award in 2005, and he holds a certification in aesthetic dentistry. He sees patients at Orion Dental Clinic in Greater Kailash 1, South Delhi. Read the full profile of Dr Anupam Sinha.

Sources

  1. NHS website. Root canal treatment (patient information). Page review date 3 October 2025. https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/root-canal-treatment/
  2. Ng YL, Mann V, Gulabivala K. Tooth survival following non-surgical root canal treatment: a systematic review of the literature. International Endodontic Journal, 2010;43(3):171-189. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20158529/
  3. Pak JG, White SN. Pain prevalence and severity before, during, and after root canal treatment: a systematic review. Journal of Endodontics, 2011;37(4):429-438. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21419285/
  4. Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. Dental implants in restorative dentistry (patient information). https://www.cuh.nhs.uk/patient-information/dental-implants-in-restorative-dentistry/
  5. Lodi G, Azzi L, Varoni EM, Pentenero M, Del Fabbro M, Carrassi A, Sardella A, Manfredi M. Antibiotics to prevent complications following tooth extractions. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2021;2:CD003811. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33624847/

Medically reviewed by Dr Anupam Sinha, BDS, MDS – Orthodontics, on . General information for patients from Orion Dental Clinic, last updated 23 October 2026. It is not advice for one person, so ask a dentist what suits you. To report an error, contact us.